FindNotary.io

Updated April 2026 · Data from public commission records and Google Business Profile listings.

Shelter Island, NY

Notary Public in Shelter Island, NY matched in 60 seconds.

Call a top-rated notary directly — or we'll text you 3 matches. Free. No account needed.

See top-rated notaries
NOTARY PUBLIC • OFFICIAL SEAL • VERIFIED •
3 Shelter Island notaries
★ 4.4 avg · 128 reviews
New York law: $2 per notarial act
Free · No account needed

★ Top-rated notaries in Shelter Island

Sorted by rating + review count

The UPS Store

★4.3(56)
Verified
Call +1 631-907-1100

Most answer within minutes

Visit website

PostalAnnex

★4.3(54)
Verified
Call +1 619-222-1664

Most answer within minutes

Visit website

Shelter Island Public Library

★4.9(9)
Verified
Call +1 631-749-0042

Most answer within minutes

Visit website

Can't reach someone? Let us text you 3 matches — usually within 2 minutes.

Can't reach anyone? We'll text you 3 matches.

Top-rated notaries in Shelter Island will get back to you — usually within minutes. Free.

Add phone and we'll text you 3 matches instantly. Otherwise we'll email you shortly.

Tell us more (optional — helps us match faster)
Free No obligation

How it works

  1. 1

    See top-rated notaries

    Verified notaries in Shelter Island, sorted by rating and review count.

  2. 2

    Call directly — or request a match

    Call the ones that fit. If nobody picks up, we'll text you 3 fresh matches in 2 minutes.

  3. 3

    Get notarized

    Mobile, in-office, or remote — your call. Free to you; notaries set their own fees (state-capped).

What it costs in Shelter Island

  • • New York state max: $2 per notarial act (by law)
  • • Walk-in (bank, UPS Store): $0–$15
  • • Mobile notary (they come to you): typically $25–$100 total including travel
  • • Loan signing: $75–$200 (includes printing & travel)
  • • Free: your bank, AAA (members), public library

Our service is always free — notaries set their own fees within state limits.

Full New York fee guide

What to bring

  • • Government-issued photo ID — driver's license, passport, or state ID
  • • The unsigned document(s) — don't sign before the notary arrives
  • • All required signers present with their own ID
  • • Witnesses if your document requires them (the notary can usually tell you in advance)
  • • Payment — most notaries accept cash, card, or Venmo/Zelle

More verified notaries in Shelter Island

3 more

The UPS Store

★ 4.3 (56)
Call Website

PostalAnnex

★ 4.3 (54)
Call Website

Shelter Island Town Hall

★ 4.0 (1)
Call Website

All Notaries in Shelter Island

CONAN INVESTIGATIONS B & W INC

Wayne A Corbett

Shelter Island, NY 11964

Commission #01CO6154423 · Expires 10/23/2026

Active
Is this you? Claim this profile

Sharon A Moritz

Shelter Island, NY 11964

Commission #02MO4872903 · Expires 11/01/2026

Active
Is this you? Claim this profile

Jack H Thilberg Jr

Shelter Island, NY 11964

Commission #01TH5081223 · Expires 06/30/2027

Active
Is this you? Claim this profile

Notaries in Nearby Cities

Nassau County 28,696 Suffolk County 25,201 New York County 23,797 Queens County 21,606 Kings County 20,300 Westchester County 16,312

Notary Guides

How Much Does a Notary Cost? State fees, mobile costs & free options Free Notary Services 8 ways to get notarized for free

Frequently Asked Questions

How many notaries are in Shelter Island, New York?▾
There are 3 active notary publics in Shelter Island, New York (Suffolk County).
Where can I find a mobile notary in Shelter Island?▾
Several notaries in Shelter Island offer mobile services and will travel to your location. Look for notaries with "Mobile Notary" listed in their services below.
How much does a notary cost in Shelter Island, New York?▾
In New York, the maximum fee for a standard notarization is $2 per signature. Mobile notaries may charge additional travel fees, typically $25-$50 per trip.
Can I get a document notarized on weekends in Shelter Island?▾
Yes, many mobile notaries and some storefront locations in Shelter Island offer weekend and evening appointments. Contact notaries directly to confirm availability.

Need a notary in Shelter Island?

Get Connected Free